Join Bridge Winners
Is this a psyche?

MP. Both vul. LHO opens 3NT, alerted and explained as a solid minor, no outside A or K.

Partner passes. RHO thinks for a while and emerges with 5. You pass.

LHO thinks for a moment and raises this to 6.

You lead (the A, but not really relevant), and dummy appears with 8 solid clubs and the K:

4 9 K54 AKQJT932

This trouble(s,d) me, since knowing whether the 3NT opener can have a side high card is likely to have a large impact on the defen(s,c)e.

The director disagreed with my suggestion that the 3NT opener was a psyche, asserting that the GCC only makes it illegal to psyche 1 and 2 openers (which is total nonsense, of course). My request for a second opinion was declined.

It is tough to discover what the ACBL thinks a psyche really is. A search comes up with a definition of a "deviation" (deviations are OK if infrequent) as being within a Queen of the expected honour strength; which would suggest that the current hand is a psyche in ACBL terms. If it is indeed a psyche, then this is illegal per the GCC (under the section "Disallowed").

What should the director do?

Nothing
Tell opps to change CC and verbal explanation of 3N
As above with a PP
Something else (please elucidate)

Sorry, to answer polls. Registered users can vote in polls, and can also browse other users' public votes! and participate in the discussion.

Getting results...
loading...
110 Comments
Getting Comments... loading...
.

Bottom Home Top