Join Bridge Winners
Playing a match at the wrong time

Teams A and B are two of a number of teams playing in a KO tournament.  Matches are arranged between teams in the event privately, in accordance with a published timetable and draw. (For example: Round 1 has to be played by September 30th, Round 2 has to be completed by November 15th etc.)

The winners of the KO qualify to represent their region (their English County) in a national championship that takes place in June, so there is a very firm deadline for completing the event.

Team A have qualified for the final of the KO.

Team B are in the other semi-final, have agreed a date for it, but have not played it yet.  This date is after the official 'play by' date for the semi-final, but they have difficulties finding a suitable date (I don't know to what extent Team B are to blame for this rather than their opponents, or whether it was a consequence of earlier matches being played late.) Team B are strong favorites to win their semi-final match but not overwhelmingly so.

One member of Team B is going on holiday for 4 weeks immediately after their semi-final, so if they win, Team B will have very limited possible dates to play the final in time.  In fact, the only weekend they can make Team A cannot (it clashes with another national event that Team A have chosen to play in).

Team B are reluctant to weaken their team by adding another player.

Team B have suggested to Team A that they play the "final" before Team B play their semi-final, i.e. they play a 48-board match and consider the result to be the result of the final if Team B subsequently win their semi-final.

The regulations for the event do not mention this as a concept, either permitted or not permitted.

What do you think?

Illegal. They aren't allowed to play the final before the semi-final.
Perfectly legal but a crazy idea; Team A should obviously refuse.
Perfectly legal and a good idea; Team A should agree if they can find a suitable date

Sorry, to answer polls. Registered users can vote in polls, and can also browse other users' public votes! and participate in the discussion.

Getting results...
loading...
60 Comments
Getting Comments... loading...
.

Bottom Home Top