Join Bridge Winners
Sharp Practice?

West
J1093
6
9873
8743
North
86
A875
KQ42
J106
East
742
K
J1065
KQ952
South
AKQ5
QJ109432
A
A
W
N
E
S
1
P
3
P
4NT
P
5
P
7
P
P
P
D
7 South
NS: 0 EW: 0

The auction does not matter, except that NS were playing simple Blackwood in a club team game. Mr and Mrs Sharp were East-West and South, who was a reasonable player, gambled the grand when he found his partner had one ace, as the early boards were poor. He won the spade lead and led the queen of hearts, and West discarded a diamond. Declarer conceded one off, bemoaning his bad luck, and East accepted the concession with alacrity. At the half-time interval his team-mates, who had conceded 6H+1 on the board, said "unlucky you got the hearts wrong" when hearing that South had gone off. All was revealed and the TD was called. He agreed that the concession of one off could be withdrawn, but because the revoke had not been noticed until more boards had been played, he could only award a trick to NS that it was not possible to lose by normal play. This was discussed on the BBO forum, with most, including me, wanting to adjust, but I could not justify it under the Laws. Readers' thoughts?

73 Comments
Getting Comments... loading...
.

Bottom Home Top