Join Bridge Winners
UI from CHO. What may I call ethically here?

South
K106
Q6
A1072
10972
W
N
E
S
2
P
3
X
P
?
 Scoring: MP

Craig Biddle posted this as a bidding problem recently, and subsequently a lead problem for those who Passed. At my (hypothetical) table, partner pondered for awhile before producing Dble.

What are my ethical choices here?

At the table I (hypothetically) Passed and led a low trump. I emerged with +200 

The opposition, unimpressed with this singular triumph, seek comfort and succour from the director.

The director joins a directorial huddle, polls a bunch of my alleged peers, and rules against me, awarding -730 for 3HX making

 How do you advise? Appeal or not ?

 

The bidding poll produced:    The lead poll produced:

3 20%                                               6  53%

3NT 2%                                                6  44%

4 11%                                               10  3%

4 14%

4 2%

Pass 50%

 

If you appeal, how do you argue your case that your lead was inextricably linked to your Pass?

43 Comments
Getting Comments... loading...
.

Bottom Home Top