Join Bridge Winners
What is the point of this?

A couple of weeks ago, a lead problem was posed:

East
8763
10
K87532
Q4
W
N
E
S
1
P
3NT
P
P
P

Love All, IMP with 20 VP scale.  N/S are playing strong NT, 5-card majors, 1 can be as short as one.

64% voted for a diamond, 25% for a spade and 11% for a heart.

I am not proposing to discuss the merits of the various leads.  Those interested can refer to the link below.  However, we have now been told that a spade was the winner: partner had AQJx sitting over dummy's King and the 3NT bid was apparently based on 10xx Kxxx AQ 10xxx.

I cannot see the point of submitting problems where the opposing bidding bears so little relation to reality.  It might be bridge, but it's not bridge as we know it.

http://bridgewinners.com/article/view/lead-problem-2-rnjlgyd8ws/?cj=662519#c662519

34 Comments
Getting Comments... loading...
.

Bottom Home Top