I thought so too Chris, but someone I mentor was getting conflicting advice from different people so it seemed like a good time to show them they can put hands up here for a wider range of opinions.
This director ruling is definitely wrong, even though it's not completely clear what the ruling should be.
Firstly the director should have given the last player to take a call from the other side a chance to take a call. If this was the person asserting they would have ...
I think playing the beer card game helps intermediate players. It gives a reason to focus on all of the spot cards in one suit at a time when they are learning to count the hands, which improves the technique for later counting the full hand.
It seems obvious that you should not be on an appeals committee where you are deciding who you will play in your next match. I'm surprised the player in this position did not recuse themselves after realizing what was happening.
I think the director should be called when people are playing illegal methods *even if you don't have any trouble coping with them*.
There are methods I would like to play that I think are better than what I am allowed to play under GCC rules that I don ...
This hand is both too good overall and too good for play in spades to bid 3♦. It would be different if your spades were xx instead of J10. I prefer to stretch with 2♦ so I can bid and rebid them to 1NT which doesn't come ...