Join Bridge Winners

Bridge Winners Profile for Rui Marques

Rui Marques
Rui Marques
  • 9
    Following
  • 37
    Followers
  • 36
    Posts
  • 0
    Favorites

Basic Information

Member Since
July 15, 2014
Last Seen
3 hours ago
Member Type
Bridge Player
about me

EBL Chief TD, WBF Chief TD.

My views and opinions expressed on BW are purely personal and do not reflect EBL/WBF positions on the matters discussed.

Sometimes staying in the USA, Philadelphia, sometimes staying in Portugal, Cascais 

Country
United States of America

Bridge Information

Favorite Tournaments
Madeira International Open
BBO Username
lusobrasil
ACBL Ranking
None
Sorry, this user has no cards yet.
Pass out of Turn
They’re both comparable bids
Rui Marques's bidding problem: J6 KJ4 KJ43 KJ42
I found it a bit odd (the mechanics of the case) because if the opener bids something the BIT before 5H doesn't seem to show anything but if there is a pass if sure looks like UI is used, especially if it's a regular partnership
Rui Marques's bidding problem: J6 KJ4 KJ43 KJ42
And so it is... 5H passed... Case from a fellow TD. 5H bidder argued that 5D had no meaning in the system (!) but 5H was to play (!!!)
Rui Marques's bidding problem: J6 KJ4 KJ43 KJ42
And second question, a long hesitation before 5hearts, what does it say to you?
Interesting Ruling Situation
The TD could have done a better job on this one...
First unpleasant experience of changed 2017 Laws
A "genuine mistake" is not a reason to accept a change of bid. Did the player intend to (mistakenly) bid 5 hearts? Did he miscount? If he doesn't convince me that he pulled the wrong card, he doesn't change. It's s judgment call. I believe all players ...
Odd ruling
wrong ruling unless the declarer can convince director that he absolutely knows the hj will be high. And even if he does, there's always the possibility that, having given up on the hand, declarer will not even notice the cards that the defense plays. Declarer just gave up... so ...
Odd ruling
No, we can adjudicate the claim on its merits. Play ceased.
Odd ruling
I'm out of adjectives for this ruling... if facts were just as written. Did the td really allow declarer to play it out ???
Odd ruling
Or because he is not paying attention anymore?
.

Bottom Home Top