Death to all kibitzers - Vol. 1

Suppose that there is a slam game going on (not very popular) in an IMP tournament.

Suppose a kibitz explodes and shouts on the declarer "YOU HAVE TO CASH AK IT IS OBVIOUS THAT Q IS BEHIND". Kibitz saw the cards (all 4 hands for whatever reason). The declarer was weighting chances and couldn't decide - now he calls TD - he doesn't want to use additional information and he's not sure how he'd play.

Suppose it does make sense to play either way.

Suppose that the average score was +650 so: -50 makes -12 IMPs for the declarer and +1430 makes 13 IMPS for the declarer

It actually happened.

Suppose that without this one board the scores look like this:

1. A + 50 IMP
2. B + 49 IMP
3. C + 48 IMP
4. D + 40 IMP
5. E + 39 IMP

Yeah, you guess it - the problem occurred on table between D and E.

kill the kibitz and rule +13/+12 and defend vs furious A, B and C
kill the kibitz and award +3/+3 and defend vs furious D and E
kill the kibitzz and award 50% -1 and 50% = for both sides (+0.5/-0.5 IMP) defend vs furious D and E
kill the kibitz, steal his money, buy with it 4 more gold medals and give them to D and E
run away and let them kill the kibitz
no biggie - I'll post my solution in the comment

Sorry, you need to be logged in to answer polls. Registered users can vote in polls, and can also browse other users' public votes! Please join our community and participate in the discussion.

Getting results...