Join Bridge Winners
In the Midst of a Mistake

It seems that most of the appeal case studies on the ACBL website involve misinformation (MI) and unauthorized information (UI). So I would like to see how you would rule on a auction that occurred at our local club last week.

End of the auction, South called the director on some possible UI or MI during the auction. I guess it's still unauthorized information that partner correctly explains the meaning of a mistaken bid.

West alerted the 3D bid as a transfer to hearts. West then passed a timid 4 bid. Transfers are marked on their CC and East commented to the director he did have 4 hearts. EW players were flight B/C players and are not strong on conventions. BTW, 4D down 2 was a poor result.

West
KJ5
K87
AK3
QJ95
North
Q10986
AJ
1072
A103
East
A2
10654
QJ9654
4
South
743
Q932
8
K8762
W
N
E
S
1
P
2
2NT
P
3
P
3
P
4
?
D

43 Comments
Getting Comments... loading...
.

Bottom Home Top