Join Bridge Winners
More Legal Eagles (push poll)

Before we start. I KNOW this is a UI case and the UI definitely suggests that partner has forgotten the system.

The problem is that the partnership do not have an agreement on what the call means - and my argument is that no call can therefore be regarded as a logical alternative -

Law 16B states (in part)

(a) A player may not choose a call or play that is demonstrably suggested over another by unauthorized information if the other call or play is a logical alternative.

"(b) A logical alternative is an action that a significant proportion of the class of players in question, using the methods of the partnership, would seriously consider, and some might select."

 Law 73 states

1. When a player has available to him unauthorized information from his partner, such as froma remark, question, explanation, gesture, mannerism, undue emphasis, inflection, haste or hesitation, an unexpected alert or failure to alert, he must carefully avoid taking any advantage from that unauthorized information [see Law 16B1(a)].

The Auction

2 (various strong hands) - 2 (+ve <3 controls)

2N (22-23 balanced) - 3 (transfer to hearts, not alerted)

5 (after a tank) : 5NT

I do not have the actual hand - you may presume 8 -10 points and 5 hearts, nothing special in diamonds, but not a void/ singleton either. (If this is not enough please feel free to say how the hand would affect your decision.)

The AI tells us that partner has forgotten the system. Any Call is allowable.
Passing is a logical alternative and is demonstrably suggested over 5NT
5 is a logical alternative and is demonstrably suggested over 5NT
6 is a logical alternative and is demonstrably suggested over 5NT
Other call is a logical alternative and is demonstrably suggested over 5NT (please say which)

Sorry, to answer polls. Registered users can vote in polls, and can also browse other users' public votes! and participate in the discussion.

Getting results...
loading...
24 Comments
Getting Comments... loading...
.

Bottom Home Top