Join Bridge Winners
Should table result be adjusted?

I'm looking to receive opinions whether the table result should be adjusted on this board:

West
AQJ106
A7
Q82
KJ9
North
9543
K842
J4
A74
East
K8
5
A10965
Q8653
South
72
QJ10963
K73
102
W
N
E
S
2
P
P
P
D
2 South
NS: 0 EW: 0

West asked about the alert and North replied "Flannery, 5 hearts, 4 spades, 11-15 HCP".  That is, in fact, the partnership agreement.  South had forgotten.

West led a diamond and declarer soon was scoring up +110, with black suit game available for EW.

Not being a fan of trying to identify as choice buttons particular reasons for opinions, I have left out choice buttons, but would propose some options in text:

  • No adjustment.  NS just got lucky.
  • No adjustment.  West contributed too severely to the result by choosing to pass over 2.
  • No adjustment.  East should balance with a singleton heart.
  • Adjustment.  North's failure to take further action opposite the expected major suit lengths of his partner suggests he has taken advantage of some UI: he picked up something from South's reaction to his explanation of the partnership agreement, or from partnership experience.
36 Comments
Getting Comments... loading...
.

Bottom Home Top