Join Bridge Winners
Which of these are legal?

For the sake of argument, ACBL regulations (also interested in EBU/WBF if laws-experts want to offer an opinion), say at Mid-Chart (although for once, I don't think the level of chart matters).

As far as I'm aware, there's some rule about not psyching artificial opening bids (what is it? And is that it? e.g. psyching a control in a cuebidding sequence seems normal practice). In this poll, I'm also trying to clarify what counts as natural/artificial.

For the sake of discussion, you are third seat, after two passes.

1) As far as I can tell, 4-4-3-2 can now open 1 "naturally" without an alert. Your system specifies that 1 could-be-two only on 4-4-3-2 shape.

After Pass - (Pass) - , you open 1 with 4-4-3-2 shape, with say 0-3 HCP (you're certain ops have 26+ HCP between them). 

 

2) You now play a balanced-or-natural club, that is you would open 1 on all semi-balanced hands outside of your 1NT opening range (most 4333, 4432, or 5332 hands without a 5-card major, or maybe five diamonds). Alternatively, your 1 opening actually has clubs.

You open 1 with in-range shape (say 3-4-4-2) and psychic HCP (say 0-3 HCP again). 

Bonus: can you ever open a psychic 1 here, even when you hold the "natural" club option. If yes, does 3-2-3-5 (the balanced shape) qualify?

 

3) You play a precision club, where your 1 is 2+.

You open 1 without 10 HCP (I think there's a HCP requirement), say:  xxx xxx AKQ109x x

Bonus: What if your 1 opening promised 3+, or even, somehow 4+?

 

So what's legal? For the purposes of answering the poll, please disregard what you think should be legal, or whether or not you think the bids made are "good" or "bad" bridge bids -- but do please leave a comment if you have an opinion on those matters.

Bonus: if any of the above are legal, can any become ... expected

None
1 only
2 only
3 only
1+2
1+3
2+3
All
I don't know/care, and don't want my ignorance/indifference to affect this poll.

Sorry, to answer polls. Registered users can vote in polls, and can also browse other users' public votes! and participate in the discussion.

Getting results...
loading...
59 Comments
Getting Comments... loading...
.

Bottom Home Top