Join Bridge Winners

Bridge Winners Profile for David MacRae

David MacRae
David MacRae
  • 1
    Following
  • 9
    Followers
  • 37
    Posts
  • 0
    Favorites

Basic Information

Member Since
Aug. 3, 2015
Last Seen
3 hours ago
Member Type
Bridge Player

Bridge Information

ACBL Ranking
None
Gabriel Tawil & David MacRae
Copy to my cards View/Print
How strongly do you feel?
I really cannot conceive of leading anything other than the Jack of diamonds. It's a good attacking lead and I don't see that anything else is safer. A club or a spade could indeed turn out to be better but the odds have to be with the diamond.
ATB: Missed Slam (corrected)
And, yes, I agree that West should have cuebid over 4NT. I said that earlier. This does not excuse the atrocious double of 6 diamonds. By far the worst bid in the auction.
ATB: Missed Slam (corrected)
It seems that I have to repeat this. 5 showed clear-cut confidence that the contract would make. In view of this, the double of 6 is simply atrocious. I have absolutely no idea how anyone can defend it. And, in fact, no one has even tried to.
Was this the correct ruling?
If I was North and I thought I knew what they were playing then, in the absence of an alert, I would ask. Maybe they've changed their system since I last talked to them. Honestly, I would ask before making any call other than Pass, whether I knew them ...
ATB: Missed Slam (corrected)
I really find it difficult to understand all the hate piled on West for this hand. While I would have doubled 1, the Pass is certainly not shameful and probably would be the majority choice in a bidding poll. East then bid a practical 4 showing about 8-9 ...
Was this the correct ruling?
This. [quote]If South is an experienced player, then the rational thing to do would be to ask about 3♣ before bidding 5♣.[/quote] I can find no justification for the 5 call and therefore would let the table result stand.
French Convention/Treatment "Call Cue-Bid": (1m)-1M-(1N)-2m
Yes. Nicely done. Just to add, cue-bid d'appel should be translated as takeout cue-bid as the author clearly derived the term from the French for takeout double.
ATB: Missed Slam (corrected)
East doubled.
Who should have taken the bull by its horns?
North underbid massively. Any opening bid with two useful cards is enough for game. His bidding would have been reasonable with one less spade and one less diamond. Say the same high cards with 6-2-3-2 distribution. I mean, come on! On top of that he didn't even explore the ...
Congratulations to John Adams
I don't personally know John but his comments on this site have always been cogent and articulate. Congratulations!
.

Bottom Home Top